The coffee landscape in China has undergone a significant transformation in recent years, leading to a new era where players abound and competition is fiercer than everOnce thriving high-end coffee chains like Costa Coffee and Pacific Coffee have started to retreat, drawing down their shop counts in response to a downturn in the marketEven Seesaw Coffee, a darling of the specialty coffee scene, is experiencing tough times, while Oatly, often dubbed the 'father of Starbucks,' was recently sold for a staggering 16 billion yuan, posturing with a new affordable coffee brand.

As affordable coffee becomes a necessity, Starbucks, a staple for high-end coffee lovers, is encountering its own set of challenges regarding growthQuestions surrounding its future abound; reports suggest that certain shopping centers are contemplating the removal of Starbucks shops, opting not to extend existing lease agreements—a notion that would have been unthinkable not long ago.

The crux of the matter lies in whether there is still room for Starbucks in China’s diverse coffee marketTo investigate this, an analysis by a local agency conducted interviews and surveys, uncovering that Starbucks is, in fact, recalibrating its strategy in light of these changes.

Initially, coffee chains primarily expanded their footprint in tier-one cities, a strategy that Starbucks adopted as wellAccording to data, as of January 2023, nearly 80% of Starbucks locations were situated in tier-two cities or higherHowever, the company is now not only maintaining its focus on major cities but is also making significant strides in penetrating lower-tier markets, venturing into county towns.

This year, Wang Tingting, a young professional, returned to her hometown of Longyan City in Fujian province and was astonished to discover a Starbucks in this small city of less than 400,000 residentsFurthermore, in January, Starbucks also opened its first outlet in Teng County, Guangxi, drawing hordes of curious customers on its opening day

Advertisements

Likewise, a recent opening took place in a village in Ningbo, showcasing the brand's aggressive expansion into less populated areas.

Now, Starbucks reportedly covers over 1,000 county-level markets across ChinaIn a fiercely competitive environment beset by price wars, Starbucks continues quietly to claim prime locations, thereby increasing its market penetration.

This dual approach of nurturing both high-end and lower-tier market expansions exemplifies Starbucks' optimism regarding its growth prospects in China’s coffee scene and reflects the broader trajectory of the coffee industry as a whole.

China's coffee market has reached a pivotal turning pointWhile the rapid growth of coffee chain establishments is slowing and funding heat is dissipating, leading to diminished expansion opportunities, statistics indicate that the new stores from 23 coffee chains in 2024 will decline by 47.4% year-on-year, with disclosed financing amounting to a mere 400 million yuan.

On the other hand, the penetration rate of chain coffee outlets is surging, manifesting a pronounced Matthew effect where leading brands enjoy substantial advantages in supply chains and scales, making it increasingly difficult for smaller brands to surviveAs a top-tier player, Starbucks aims to enhance its market penetration to reinforce brand influence while expanding its customer loyalty base.

Moreover, as the coffee market in major cities begins to saturate, there remain untapped opportunities within lower-tier marketsAccording to Deloitte, coffee consumption among consumers in tier-one and tier-two cities averages 326 cups and 261 cups annually, respectively, while the national average lags at just 9 cups per year, revealing considerable consumption potential in lower-tier markets.

The awakening of "coffee genetic" in lower-tier markets is evidentThe 2024 Coffee Market Insight Report indicates that delivery orders for coffee in cities below tier four have surpassed a staggering 100% year-on-year growth, with the northeast and northwest regions skyrocketing by over 180%.

These developments point to a wealth of opportunity for Starbucks in China

Advertisements

In its latest quarterly results, Starbucks disclosed that newly opened stores in lower-tier and new county-level markets have consistently outperformed those in major cities.

The primary consumer demographics are also evolvingWith rising awareness surrounding coffee, consumers are increasingly treating coffee as an essential part of their daily lives, thus enhancing the frequency and commonality of coffee consumptionOn top of that, the habit of instant gratification in coffee consumption is forming, compelling coffee brands to enhance purchasing convenience.

Opening new stores remains an effective approach to bolstering market coverage and meeting this consumer demandImproved convenience fosters a sense of reliance on certain brands, ultimately solidifying consumer loyalty.

As Starbucks accelerates its lower-tier market penetration, it continues optimizing its high-end market presence by shuttering poorly performing storesObservations show that, in 2024 alone, Starbucks has closed at least six long-running stores, some of which had been operational for over a decadeAt the same time, it explores emerging shopping districts, crafting strategic outposts around community needs, even opening a store at a lofty 3050-meter elevation on Yulong Snow Mountain.

In terms of store openings, Starbucks has shattered multiple records; during the entire 2024 fiscal year, the brand added 790 new locations, reflecting a yearly growth of 12%, setting a historical benchmarkAdding to the excitement, it has ventured into 166 new county-level markets, effectively doubling its reach compared to the previous fiscal year, with lower-tier cities contributing an unprecedented share of new openings.

Simultaneously, Starbucks remains committed to enhancing its "third space" positioning—providing consumers with a space that transcends residential or work environments, reimagined as informal public gathering areasThe recent opening of a historic-style Starbucks in the scenic area of Putuo Mountain showcases this ambition, complete with an antique aesthetic that evokes feelings of nostalgia while simultaneously embracing modern functional needs.

This expressiveness isn't an isolated incident; stores in various locations across the country also blend traditional and modern aesthetics to enrich the "third space" experience

Advertisements

For instance, locations in Ningbo and Xi'an will blend local artistry and architectural heritage seamlessly with contemporary sensibilities, reinforcing cultural ties and community connections.

Furthermore, selections include specialized store types that cater to diverse consumer needs, including sign language-friendly outlets and pet-friendly establishmentsWith over 20 sign language venues, more than 450 pet-friendly stores, and upwards of 1400 eco-friendly locations across the nation, Starbucks is innovating to resonate with varying consumer demographics effectively.

The brand’s commitment to revitalizing older shops cannot be understatedMonthly, an average of Starbucks stores are refreshed, with notable updates seen in 33 outlets throughout Shanghai, enhancing service delivery to both new and loyal customers alike.

Additionally, Starbucks fuses traditional, intangible cultural heritages with contemporary offerings, enriching the "third space" concept with deep cultural relevanceFor instance, its heritage concept store in Nanjing showcases local cultural narratives and artistry embedded within the consumer experience, presenting a unique coupling of coffee culture, and local history.

This not only provides a platform for heritage craft to be displayed and passed down but also enriches consumers' experiences, instilling a sense of emotional connection that strengthens the brand's relationship with its customers.

In this fierce competitive landscape, while many brands are trending towards smaller, lighter store types, Starbucks' pursuit of immersive "third spaces" suggests a careful consideration of market positioning and customer expectationsThis proactive stance still echoes their core ethos of hospitality and community-creating spaces that invite gathering and socializationQuality space is integral to meeting consumers' relaxation and interaction needs, making consistent upgrades and innovations both necessary and sensible.

Starbucks also recognizes the increasingly discerning nature of consumer demands, leveraging this awareness to elevate expectations through modernized experiences that refresh brand associations while appealing to younger demographics

Moreover, the incorporation of local culture into the Starbucks experience infuses a sense of respect and stewardship, fortifying the emotional connection between the brand and its consumer base.

Starbucks' "third space" strategy has created a plethora of possibilities, enabling them to expand their offerings—such as premium roasting workshops, exclusive stores, and eco-friendly outlets—all designed to invite a diverse consumer demographic to share in experiences extending beyond mere coffee consumptionThis approach is vital for maintaining brand integrity whilst cultivating a dedicated consumer base.

In closing, Starbucks is not only recalibrating its store development strategies and innovating its "third space" concept but also actively adjusting its operational facets to align with market dynamicsThe company is demonstratively working toward developing offerings that resonate with Chinese customers and continually advancing marketing techniquesAs the fiscal year unfolded, Starbucks China reported a net profit of $783.7 million, reflecting a 6% increase quarter-on-quarter when excluding currency fluctuationsThroughout the entire fiscal year, the operating profit margin remained healthily in the double digits, thanks to ongoing localization efforts and adaptations to a rapidly changing landscape.

Starbucks demonstrates a thoughtful response to the intensifying competition facing many brands—it advocates identifying unique selling propositions and diligently refining distinct advantages to maintain relevance in a crowded marketAmid doubts about its long-term viability, many consumers affirm their loyalty to the beloved "third space," proclaiming that only Starbucks cultivates such enriching experiencesUndoubtedly, this showcases Starbucks’ indispensable role in the evolving landscape of China’s coffee market.

Such tactical wisdom positions Starbucks favorably to navigate through turbulent times, serving as a potential model for other brands grappling with similar existential challenges in this fiercely competitive arena.

Advertisements

Advertisements